What's interesting to note is that while we might think we're the only ones saying these things, that they're unique to our set of friends, that's really not the case. The Internet spreads all of this around, so just when you think you've got a vernacular all to yourself, you find that no, completely random people from across the country or globe are borrowing your words. Case in point from textism.com:
Perhaps things like Blog Hot-or-Not contribute to this. I definitely recall seeing others, particularly of the feh/meh/beh brand, in the past.
You should follow me on Twitter.